Something I Just Don’t Understand Anymore

People complaining about double dipping.  If you do not know what I mean about double dipping, well, you must not buy many DVDs.

I kid, I kid…in the world of home video, double dipping refers to studios re-releasing previously released material with added bonus material.  Sometimes the studios are very open about this, both Lord of the Rings and the Watchmen announced extended cuts to be coming down the road.  Harry Potter is releasing Ultimate Blu-Rays for each movie.  The new sets have pretty much all the original whistles and bells, but also have new material-such as extended cuts (basically, the versions we saw on television) and theatrical cuts, an eight part documentary split up among each set, individual picture books and HP cards.  Simply put, there are really nice sets.

Double dipping predates DVDs, so it’s been going on a good fifteen years or more.  In the rush to get their catalogs on DVD, many studios put out quickie versions of their DVDs to try and take advantage of the new technologies.  These were not cheap DVDs, but they had little in the way of special features.  Companies like Anchor Bay and Lionsgate were the few really taking advantage of what DVD could do.  When special editions came out later, people didn’t complain to much…until DVDs became the defacto digital movie viewing choice by consumers.  Then people were seeing stuff they already owned on DVD hotting DVD again.  This has rarely bothered me.  I like the special edition.  Now, in some cases, I did not make the leap to the DVD if I had the VHS until there was a special edition.  But I’ve never really felt upset when I purchased a DVD and later the special edition came out.

Admittedly, I buy plenty of stuff used or at a great discount.  So, maybe that’s why I am really bothered by the practice.

Is it “greedy”?  Yeah.  Is it actually morally wrong or even unfair?  No.  It makes a lot of sense.  The companies want to take their most successful franchises and films and keep them working for them.  You may not like it, but it is hardly criminal.

If this was a new development, I could see the anger.  But, geez, people should be used to this by now.  Why do people get shocked that there is no end in site.  And for you people arguing digital online viewing is the wave of the future (I just call that On-Demand)…trust me…the studios will find a way to suck your cash out repeatedly agin.  I suspect the days of “owning” a movie will die the minute we stop having a hard disc edition.  Parents, you know that will suck, since children like to watch stuff over and over.

(One sympathy…if you literally just bought an entire movie series and find out later that the uber-version is about to be released…)

2 thoughts on “Something I Just Don’t Understand Anymore

  1. I believe it was Mark Evanier who coined the acronym W.W.C.T.G.Y.T.B.N.C.O.S.Y.A.O. http://rogerowengreen.blogspot.com/2009/05/wwctgytbncosyao-question.html

    You may be savvy enough to read that the first edition is coming out six months after the film, then the “deluxe” version six months after that. But not everyone follows those things spo closely.
    They might by Season 1 of a show, then Season 2. Then Season 3 is only available with the 1st two. Or that special crossover is only available in the box set. It bothers because there’s a finite amount of time & money, and buying it twice bugs people.

    BTW, double dipping in govt, at least in NYS, means something entirely else – getting two or three pensions simultaneously.

  2. –You may be savvy enough to read that the first edition is coming out six months after the film, then the “deluxe” version six months after that. But not everyone follows those things so closely.–

    But this late in the game? It does not require you to be that savvy. It merely requires you to have purchased some DVDs in the last fifteen years. This is not even kind of new-it goes back to VHS.

    Add to that, nobody seems to complain about new editions of books, yet publishers will re-release multiple editions of books-to tie them to movies that are based on them, new books in that author’s series, etc. I can’t recall cries of conspiracy to get people to buy the Chronicles of Narnia yet again.

    –They might by Season 1 of a show, then Season 2. Then Season 3 is only available with the 1st two. Or that special crossover is only available in the box set. It bothers because there’s a finite amount of time & money, and buying it twice bugs people.–

    This is an entirely different and unethical practice. It is also incredibly rare, and the few instances I have seen it happen, the studio recognized the anger and released that previously unavailable season on it’s own.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s